When is a defendant's file referred to the Grand Mufti in Egypt, and is a death sentence invalid if his opinion was not sought?

A defendant's file is referred to the Grand Mufti of Egypt when a Felony Court is inclined to impose the death penalty: the court may only do so unanimously and after obtaining the Mufti's opinion. The opinion is advisory and does not bind the court, but seeking it is a condition for the sentence's validity, and a death sentence issued without it is void. Referral is not a death sentence; it is a step before judgment is pronounced at a later hearing.

Why is this in the news?

It was reported on 15 November 2026 that the Sohag Felony Court referred the files of fifteen defendants, in a case arising from a clash between two families, to the Grand Mufti and set 22 December for pronouncing judgment. No judgment has been issued, the case is still pending, and the defendants are presumed innocent until a final judgment. We therefore do not comment on its facts or evidence and only explain the legal rule.

When does the court refer the file to the Mufti?

Article 365 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, Law No. 174 of 2025, provides that the Felony Court, at both levels, may only impose a death sentence by unanimous decision of its members and must first obtain the opinion of the Grand Mufti. If the Mufti's opinion does not arrive in good time before the scheduled hearing, the court proceeds to judgment.

Unanimity is required when judgment is issued, not at referral: in Appeal No. 14917 of Judicial Year 91, session of 9 March 2024 (from the firm's Cassation library), the Court of Cassation held that the law requires unanimity only when the death sentence is pronounced, not at the earlier step of seeking the Mufti's opinion.

In practice, referral signals that the court is provisionally inclined towards the death penalty, but it has not ruled and may impose a different penalty at the judgment hearing.

Is the court bound by the Mufti's opinion?

No. The opinion is advisory: the court must seek it but need not follow it, and the decision remains the court's alone. The obligation concerns the procedure, not the outcome.

Is a death sentence invalid if the Mufti's opinion was not sought?

Yes. In Appeal No. 56449 of Judicial Year 76, session of 4 February 2007 (Technical Office 58, p. 113) (from the firm's Cassation library), the Court of Cassation held that seeking the Mufti's opinion before a death sentence is a necessary condition for the judgment's validity required by law, and that having sought it at an earlier trial does not substitute for seeking it again.

In Appeal No. 5009 of Judicial Year 91, session of 8 June 2024 (from the firm's Cassation library), the Court confirmed that both unanimity and the Mufti's opinion are required for a valid death sentence.

What about the Appellate Felony Court?

The words "at both levels" in Article 365 mean the requirement also applies before the Appellate Felony Court when it is inclined to impose death. By analogy, Appeal No. 56449 of Judicial Year 76 supports this: an opinion sought at an earlier trial does not replace seeking it before the new bench that issues the judgment.

Youm7 reported on 4 November 2026 that the Court of Cassation's General Assembly for Criminal Matters held that the Mufti's opinion must be sought again before the Appellate Felony Court. We could not locate this ruling in the firm's library, so we mention it only as a press report [needs verification].

Does a death sentence go to the Court of Cassation even without an appeal?

Yes. Article 46 of Law No. 57 of 1959 on appeals before the Court of Cassation requires the Public Prosecution to submit any case in which a death sentence was issued in the defendant's presence to the Court of Cassation with a memorandum of its opinion, and Article 412 of the Code of Criminal Procedure refers to this rule where the death sentence is not appealed. An appeal in cassation suspends execution of a death sentence (Article 442).

Relevant rulings (from the firm's Cassation library): Appeal No. 45127 of Judicial Year 76, session of 6 December 2006 (Technical Office 57, p. 938); Appeal No. 21267 of Judicial Year 76, session of 5 November 2006 (Technical Office 57, p. 851); and Appeal No. 22878 of Judicial Year 73, session of 6 January 2004, on the sixty-day deadline for submission. The Court reviews the case of its own motion even if the prosecution misses the deadline.

Specialist legal opinion

Egyptian law surrounds the death penalty with three linked safeguards: unanimity of the bench when judgment is issued, the Mufti's opinion before pronouncement, and mandatory review by the Court of Cassation. A breach of any of them is a substantial ground of challenge. With the creation of Appellate Felony Courts, the words "at both levels" in Article 365 make consulting the Mufti mandatory at every level where the court is inclined to impose death.

Sources reviewed for the data in this article

Frequently asked questions

When is a defendant's file referred to the Grand Mufti?

When the Felony Court, at either level, is inclined to impose the death penalty, since it must obtain the Mufti's opinion before pronouncing it (Article 365).

Does referral to the Mufti mean a death sentence?

No. Referral precedes judgment, and the court may impose a different penalty at the judgment hearing.

Is the court bound by the Mufti's opinion?

No. The opinion is advisory; the court must seek it but need not follow it, and if it does not arrive in time the court proceeds to judgment.

Is a death sentence invalid if the Mufti was not consulted?

Yes. Seeking the Mufti's opinion is a condition for a valid death sentence, and an opinion sought at an earlier trial does not replace it.

Is a death sentence reviewed by the Court of Cassation without an appeal?

Yes. The Public Prosecution must submit the case to the Court of Cassation within sixty days under Article 46 of Law No. 57 of 1959.

If you have a problem and are not sure whether it falls under the subject of this article, you can consult a specialist lawyer by booking a consultation on our website.

Related articles

Related services

If you are a party to a similar problem, do not face it alone; contact our firm or pay us a visit, so that we may place our experience at your service and handle your case with the care and precision it deserves.

Book a consultation

If you have worked with our firm, we would be glad if you rated your experience on Google: Rate us on Google

This article is general information for legal awareness and does not replace legal advice on your particular situation.